The Fruitcake
Failed to add items
Add to basket failed.
Add to wishlist failed.
Remove from wishlist failed.
Adding to library failed
Follow podcast failed
Unfollow podcast failed
Get 30 days of Standard free
The Fruitcake
Buy Now for £6.59
-
Narrated by:
-
Annalee Scott
-
Danny Montooth
-
By:
-
Leah Orr
Summary
The Fruitcake - A deadly twist on a popular Christmas tradition
Four friends, one fruitcake, and a ritzy town full of secrets . . .
What could go wrong?
When Holly Kelly moves from Miami to the lavish Laguna Palms neighborhood, seeking community and friendship-with her husband and rambunctious triplets in tow-she finds it in spades. She is soon drawn into the intimate lives of almost everyone in their beachfront cul-de-sac, especially her three new ride-or-dies: Gina, Greta, and Chloe.
But when the neighborhood's holiday fruitcake exchange takes a dark turn, the bodies start piling up. The deaths seem like accidents-at first. Meanwhile, their upscale suburb on the shores of Hutchinson Island, Florida, is also being plagued by a series of disturbing disappearances. Men vanish, then reappear in the neighborhood . . . but changed.
The four friends decide to do some sleuthing of their own, and what they find chills them to the bone. When it's Holly's turn to deliver a fruitcake to the Hudson sisters on Christmas Eve four years later, she hears screaming coming from inside the house . . . many different voices-and they don't sound female.
Can they uncover the twisted secrets of Laguna Palms before someone closer to home becomes yet another casualty?
The Fruitcake is a fast-paced thriller that drips with murder, mayhem, and delightful, often delicious Southern hospitality while split narration spins the tale from alternate perspectives. If you enjoyed the TV series Desperate Housewives, you'll love The Fruitcake-a twisty murder mystery you won't soon forget.
©2023 Leah Orr (P)2025 Leah OrrListener received this title free
A review copy of this book was sent to me by the author. All of the above opinions are my own.
An intricately plotted story.
Something went wrong. Please try again in a few minutes.
Listener received this title free
Thrilling and fun
Something went wrong. Please try again in a few minutes.
The casting for this audiobook is superb. The narrators, Annalee Scott and Danny Montooth, do a masterful job of handling the dual perspectives of the suburban mystery and the terrifying captive subplot. Annalee Scott expertly handles the main neighbourhood story, bringing the perfect mix of cosy familiarity and mounting paranoia, while Danny Montooth voices 'the captive' with a raw, urgent, and chilling delivery. The distinct performances make it easy to follow the two intertwining threads of the mystery and truly heightens the overall tension.
Overall:
Orr perfectly executes the 'Cosy-to-Chaos' transition, giving The Fruitcake a neighbourhood thriller vibe akin to films like The Cottage or Hot Fuzz. The prologue grounds the story in classic holiday charm: we are immediately introduced to the cute town, the main character Holly (whose name couldn't be more perfect!), and the delightful, ritualistic neighbourhood Christmas fruitcake exchange. But this very festive ritual is what sets the stage for the suspense.
The cosy charm is violently broken when Holly witnesses a murder, turning a simple community exchange into the ultimate high-stakes hook. It's a quick, compelling introduction that promises a much darker treat than its title suggests.
The cosy-thriller elements are brilliantly balanced by pitch-black humour. You quickly realise this isn't your average neighbourhood murder when the first cause of death is linked to the fruitcake exchange, specifically due to the bizarre, accidental inclusion of Lego! This absurdity is heightened by the narrator's knowledge that this is not the last death by fruitcake in neighbouring history. It's a deliciously weird detail that provides a unique, compelling hook, promising a truly unpredictable narrative.
The clever inclusion of a secondary Point of View by 'the captive' immediately elevates the stakes. We, the readers, are given just enough access to this unknown person's terrifying reality—not knowing who he is or the reasons for his capture—which makes the quiet, small-town mystery of the fruitcake exchange feel intensely connected to a much larger, darker, and more intriguing plot. It’s a masterful way to keep the reader off-balance.
The mystery quickly escalates beyond the absurdity of the 'Lego-in-the-fruitcake' death. Just as the neighborhood settles into shock, one of the central figures seems to vanish without a trace. No witnesses, no explanation—they simply disappeared. This immediate complication brilliantly raises the stakes and forces the reader (and the main character) to ask the central, chilling question: Is this missing neighbor somehow connected to the terrifying subplot of 'the captive'? It’s a compelling twist that transforms a simple death into a desperate search.
The book masterfully uses timing to turn bad luck into a pattern of dread. When the community is hit by a second, equally strange accident the year after the initial Lego-in-the-fruitcake death, it becomes terrifyingly clear that the neighbourhood’s festive fruitcake pact is far more impactful than anyone realised. This grim recurrence suggests that the community is under some sort of curse or consequence tied directly to its customs, ensuring the tension never lets up.
As the layers of the fruitcake mystery are peeled back, the neighbourhood itself transforms from a picture-perfect setting into something far more insidious. The intense focus on the good of the neighbourhood and its residents begins to feel less about being neighbourly and more about absolute conformity. The story masterfully reveals a chilling, cult-like atmosphere beneath the pristine surface, making every interaction feel slightly off-kilter and incredibly creepy. You realise their dedication to the community is actually the source of its greatest danger.
What truly elevates this novel is its unflinching look at community judgment. The author sets up a scenario where the neighbourhood acts as an impromptu moral jury, but their focus is strangely skewed. The book asks us to consider: Who are we to decide which sins are forgivable? It’s a powerful commentary on selective outrage and the hypocrisy hidden behind closed doors.
This book captures the essence of small-town gossip warped by sinister events. The titular fruitcake becomes less of a dessert and more of a harbinger of chaos. You'll feel the atmosphere of neighbourhood paranoia escalating with every scene. Even the UPS driver starts looking questioning a cake, that's how effective the mounting sense of dread is!
Rating out of 5: Performance 5/5:
The superb casting and execution by Annalee Scott and Danny Montooth perfectly managed the tricky dual narrative. Their distinct voices and compelling, urgent delivery for the captive storyline heightened the tension and made the listening experience truly immersive.
Story 4/5:
The story earns high marks for its brilliant balance of dark humour (Lego-in-the-fruitcake) and genuine thriller elements. It features a masterful plot that escalates logically, offers a satisfying historical twist, and creates a unique, cult-like atmosphere of conformity and judgment.
Overall 5/5:
A truly unique and memorable 'Cosy-to-Chaos' thriller that hits its mark. The combination of the exceptional narration, the sharp writing, and the deeply satisfying, re-contextualising historical ending makes this a must-listen holiday crime drama.
Re-listenability:
The final act reveals secrets stretching back centuries and re-contextualizes the 'fruitcake curse.' A high rating here means listeners will be rewarded by a second listen to catch the masterful foreshadowing.
The World's Most Dangerous Christmas Dessert: An Audiobook Review of The Fruitcake, Leah Orr
Something went wrong. Please try again in a few minutes.
Listener received this title free
I just gave up on the day and kept listening it was so captivating and just kept drawing me in.
Excellent
Something went wrong. Please try again in a few minutes.
The twisted plot
Something went wrong. Please try again in a few minutes.