This week, we’re bringing you a little witchcraft, a little chaos, and a whole lot of “what the actual hell?”

Colleen kicks things off with the strange and still-unsolved story of who put Bella in the Wych Elm—a haunting post-war mystery involving graffiti, a hidden skeleton, and questions that have somehow refused to die.

Then Tayler takes us into one of the most bizarre paranormal cases ever recorded: the Rosenheim Poltergeist. We’re talking exploding lightbulbs, swinging office equipment, and activity so intense it had engineers, physicists, and parapsychologists all scratching their heads.

Is it supernatural? Is it psychological? Is someone—or something—just being wildly productive with their haunting schedule?

Either way… we’ve got thoughts.

🎙️ Tune in for eerie mysteries, chaotic energy, and just enough skepticism to keep things interesting.

In this episode we chat with one of the lovely people in the audience after one of our live shows, and she told us the spooky story of a haunted house in Tennessee she rented a room in. Are dead birds an omen? Would you stay in a house where you heard knocking within the closet?

Grab a blanket, get cozy, and maybe turn a light on.... and tune into this listener story episode!

Got a story to tell us? Email us at IGSTTYstories@gmail.com

Recorded live at Jarrod’s, this St. Patrick’s Day episode dives into Irish folklore and history—where luck, legend, and violence collide.

Tayler opens with the darker side of fairies and leprechauns, exploring the origins of these figures in Irish folklore, the rules surrounding the fae, and the long-standing belief that these are not creatures to take lightly.

Colleen then covers the story of the Molly Maguires, a secretive group tied to labor unrest in 19th-century Pennsylvania coal mines. What followed was a series of violent acts, controversial trials, and a legacy that still raises questions: were they criminals, or were they fighting back against exploitation?

This episode blends mythology and true crime, examining how stories of luck and mischief often mask something much more complex.