Send us Fan Mail

In this episode, we dive into the haunting and complex case of Jenny Pandos, as explored in the HBO documentary Burden of Proof. When Jenny disappeared without a trace, the story left behind raised more questions than answers—and decades later, those questions still linger.

Using Burden of Proof as our guide, we unpack the timeline of Jenny’s disappearance, examine the evidence, and explore the emotional journey of a family searching for the truth. We also take a closer look at how the case was handled and the lasting impact it has had on those closest to it.

Support the show

Send a text

In this episode, Casey and Husband Derek dive into the chilling true story behind the documentary The Scream Murder: A True Teen Horror Story. We discuss the shocking crime that rocked a small community, the influence of horror culture on the case, and the disturbing line between fiction and reality. Join us as we unpack the details of the investigation, the psychology behind the teens involved, and the questions the documentary leaves lingering. It’s a haunting conversation about obsession, influence, and how a love of horror took a terrifying turn in real life.

Support the show

Send a text

Sarah and Casey discuss the case of Aileen Wuornos, using the Netflix documentary, Aileen, Queen of the Serial Killers, as a source.

Support the show