This is the latest in a bonus content series called “B-Rations" (B for Bonus). The next full episode of POV:WW2 is due out on June 4th so keep an eye on the feed.

Sources and for further research:

"One Casualty Per Tank": Trevor N. Dupuy's analysis of 898 U.S. First Army tank losses (797 medium and 101 light tanks) confirms an average of 0.98 crew casualties per knocked-out tank.

Sherman vs. T-34 Survivability: The ORO-T-117 report corroborates that the fatality rate for Sherman crews was 24.6 percent when their tank was destroyed, compared to approximately 28 percent for T-34 crewmen.

The "Ronson" Myth & Burn Rates: A U.S. Army study from 1945 confirms that early dry-stowage Shermans had a burn rate of 60 to 80 percent, but the introduction of wet-stowage*** dropped this to between 10 and 15 percent. Dupuy's data confirms that across the First Army sample, only 40 percent of knocked-out tanks burned.

The Battle of Arracourt & The 5-to-1 Myth: The 4th Armored Division did destroy roughly 86 German tanks and assault guns for the loss of 41 Shermans. Furthermore, Steven Zaloga explicitly refutes the "five Shermans to kill a Panther" claim, stating it has no basis in historical records.

3rd Armored Division Losses: Belton Cooper's Death Traps claims the 3rd Armored Division started with 232 tanks and saw 648 completely destroyed and another 700 knocked out and repaired, arriving at a 580 percent loss rate.

The Panzer IV Comparison: The German Panzer IV burned more frequently than the Sherman; British Operational Research Section surveys found that the Panzer IV had an 80 percent burn rate when penetrated.

Relevant information not mentioned in the episode:

Lethality of Burning Tanks: Tanks that caught fire averaged 1.28 crew casualties, while those that did not burn averaged 0.78 casualties.

The Panzerfaust Danger: Operational research confirms that infantry anti-tank rockets inflicted 13 percent of the tank losses but were responsible for 21 percent of the crew casualties.

Medical Reality for Tankers: The Borden Institute's Conventional Warfare: Ballistic, Blast, and Burn Injuries explicitly confirms that armored vehicle crews suffered a "decreased overall frequency" of injury compared to infantry, but faced an "increased severity" of wounds.

Casualties Outside the Tank: Zaloga's work citing a study of 300 armored casualties in Italy confirms that 64 percent occurred when individuals were outside their tank doing maintenance or scouting.

***Starting in February 1944, the U.S. Army entirely redesigned the interior of the Sherman, relocating the main gun ammunition out of the vulnerable upper side sponsons and placing it deep in racks on the hull floor beneath the turret basket. To further protect the volatile propellant, these new floor bins were surrounded by "wet stowage" jackets filled with a liquid mixture of water and ethylene glycol (antifreeze) to prevent freezing in winter conditions. If a kinetic penetrator or shaped charge managed to strike the low-profile floor bins, the liquid jackets would rupture, instantly dousing the ammunition and drastically delaying or entirely preventing the auto-ignition of the propellant.

Experience Arthur Goldschmidt's incredible World War II story from the mud of Metz to a face-off with three Tiger Tanks. Mixed in Dolby Atmos for binaural headphone listening. Use earbuds or headphones for a uniquely powerful experience.

Find the oral history this episode is based on here.

If this episode moved you and you'd like to help bring more stories like this one to light, please consider leaving a tip at https://povww2.captivate.fm/support. Every contribution goes directly toward producing more episodes and honoring more veterans.

Episodes of POV:WW2 are dramatizations based on actual oral histories. While dialogue and narrative have been adapted for clarity, they reflect the veterans' own memories and experiences. Where a veteran's account leaves gaps, we draw on the established and verified historical record to place their experience in its full context. When a veteran's own account includes details that cannot be independently corroborated but are plausible within the established historical record, we honor their testimony and include those details in service of staying true to their experience. Any opinions about the war or its figures represent the perspectives found in the oral histories, not necessarily those of the host.

Sign up for updates and info at povww2.com

POV:WW2 brings the combat stories of American veterans to life through immersive narrative storytelling drawn from real oral history interviews. Each episode places you inside pivotal moments of humanity's greatest conflict — honoring these veterans' extraordinary sacrifice with the depth and accuracy their stories deserve.

This story is shared with the support of the Rutgers Oral History Archives, one of the most significant collections of veteran oral histories in the United States. If you've got a story you'd like to share with the ROHA, please visit https://oralhistory.rutgers.edu/

Are you ready to step into history?

This is the latest in a bonus content series called "B-Rations" (B for Bonus). The next full episode of POV:WW2 is due out on May 14th so keep an eye on the feed.